Hawking: 'God' did not create the universe
Bless you my Chappers

for providing me with an excuse
Foisted? We've a Chistian country.

Anyway, as Lee says, you can't prove the existence of God. You might see it as a cop-out but that's the nature of faith. I'm not sure I'm the right person to be presenting evidence anyway. I don't know if God exists or not. I want to beleive but I'm not sure that I can, if you get my drift.
And what's a Luddite fundamentalist? The ultimate nihilist? Someone who wants to reduce everything to its component parts? An eighteenth certury ruralist?
Now where have I ever expressed an opinion on vegetarians? Live and let live - that's my motto.
I guess ...

... I want the moral certainty, Hud. Some people say life's a game. Maybe it is so I want to know the rules. Perhaps I'm just envious of the serenity that faith brings to some. And also a lot of people who I know and admire have faith.
To think it really is ashes to ashes, dust to dust is quite depressing; frightening really.
And when push comes to shove, I love a good old sing-song in a mediaeval building. No guitars though. Faith and guitars do not mix.
Cheers, Hudley

My initial thought was "what a load of old hippy bollocks". But that's unfair to you. So you see a universal and infinite spirit that is in all of us? Christians do too. It's just you disagree with how it got there.
How do you disassociate from yourself? Your very being is not something you can switch on and off. And if you were to step outside and observe, how would you get back in?
You seem to think I lack self-awareness or maybe self-knowledge? I disagree. I know exactly who and what I am (or I know as much as I want to know) and I'm quite happy with it. Or at least I accept me, warts and all. I don't propose to go on a journey of self-discovery as that's just too self-centred. My life is defined by how I interact with others - I like to look outside, not inside. As an aside, do you ever hear of people going off to find themselves then coming back and saying "I found myself alright and I realised I'm a bit of a cunt"? Well, sometimes they do and then they change 'for the better'.
What is wrong with bowing to a higher authority? It's called humility and, as Clint said "a man's gotta know his limitations". We're not all capable of anything despite what various fuckers would have us believe and recognising what you can and can't achieve is one of the factors of a contented life.
I'd also say that what you call my dread of death is actually a love of life. The dread comes from things dropping out, falling apart and generally stopping working. I'm with Ernest Hemingway on that score.
I shall continue to ponder what you say because it's clear that you've put a lot of thought into it and although I don't agree with some of your views, I do respect them. At the moment, though, this approach just seems far too obsessed with self to the exclusion of all others. I'd prefer to have a communal sing-song than sit there gazing at my own navel.
What he said... and Marx

I'm an atheist but I agree with Donaldo's point Hud.
The best reason for God is not to explain who or how the universe was created, it's to give some context to how we should live in it.
Ignoring the nutty margins, most religious teaching is just basic stuff about how to get along with other people - it's also about having a bit of respect for something or someone beyond yourself.
Atheism is fine for sensible people like you and me Hud but when Marx described it as the opiate of the masses he also said "Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions" - fucking poetry that.
And "Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d'honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification."
I like the concept that religion is the logic of the world in popular form. Marx thought it could be replaced it with communist ethics, but since that turned out to be an epic fail, and western society has also largely abandoned it, we are struggling in a moral vacuum IMHO.
Ego

You say "Don has apparently missed the point". Don says "maybe you didn't make it very well"
And how can your being be more than your mind? I reallyy can't see that. Even the soul is part of your mind. Or perhaps we're using the term differntly.
Finally, much as I'm a fan of Blake, it was Huxley.
while agreeing with elements from each argument...

The greatest sensations are often not understood by the mind..when we feel strong emotions,are moved by a piece of music or a sunset or a baby's smile,these are not the products of rational thought but something within our being that we do not control or fully understand.
How to tap into this state is the big question..meditation?psychedlic drugs?religion?...mankind has strived to experience these states since time began and is unlikely to want to stop anytime soon.
Hud, m'friend ...

... I don't know is we are on the same page or even that I care to be. At the risk of being roundly patronised again, I can't really see the point in what you're on about. All this stuff about the sould and looking at yourself from the outside. What does it achieve? As I said before, I view relationships and social interaction as the important things - not staring up your own arse. Again, maybe I've misunderstood you but it all seems very 'me, me, me!'.
I've not studied Blake in any depth. I should have said I like his pictures and some of his poems. And I don't think what you're talking about is the same as most Enlightenment thinkers. They we'ren't about spirituality, they were characterised by the pursuit of reason - your concept, if I read it correctly, is far more spiritual. Still, while you're at the old Enlightenment thinking, how about a bit of Adam Smith? Next thing you know, you'll start to reappraise Thatcherism.
proof?
Nobody with any sense requires proof of the existence of God, but evidence would be nice and there isn't any that I can see apart from the fact that humans can understand how the universe works.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/space/7972538/Are-we-living-in-a-desi...
evidence of what?
of some "outside" influence, or of a supreme being that we should worship? despite the fact that all evidence points towards it either having no interest in our affairs or of being a bit of shit? There may or may not be a God, but there certainly isn't one worth worshipping.





http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11161493
More to come for the 'God'-fearing among you, esp. some heart-warming words for Donaldo..